I welcome any and all theorycrafting. However, don't get angry is someone fixes your math. We are all adults here. I expect everyone to act like it. But, this is the internet, so the rules are as follows.
1) No name calling
As soon as you you start calling someone a name or pick on them for their guild progression, the topic will be either pruned or locked, depending on how much nonsense has gone on.
2) Math is key
While personal experience does help, having math to back up something makes it much more likely to be accepted. We also understand we are not robots and player reaction is not the same as best stance possible for math theorycrafting.